The beer and wine conspiracy


Wine makers 'pack bottles with artificial additives'

Wine makers are packing their bottles with artificial additives that reduce wine to "alcoholic cola", according to an investigation.

In some cases producers employ water, sugar and sometimes hydrochloric acid to ensure their wine has a uniform taste and consistency.

The research into the quality of the 1.5 billion bottles consumed in Britain, for tonight's Channel 4 programme Dispatches, also cast doubt on the reputation of Champagne, with one expert suggesting that 70 per cent was not worth the premium price.

Malcolm Gluck, author of The Great Wine Swindle, said: "Many, many wines are no better than a sort of alcoholic cola. You get artificial yeasts, enzymes, sugar, extracts, tannins, all sorts of things added."

Many cheaper wines have oak chips added to give the impression that they have been aged in a traditional barrel.

Some of the most well-known new world brands use milk and enzymes to make the wine less cloudy and ensure that the wine tastes the same from one batch to the next.

More than 60 Beaujolais producers are due in court later this year accused of disguising low-quality grapes with excessive amounts of sugar.

In Italy 70 million litres was seized and was found to comprise just 20 per cent wine, the remainder being water, sugar and ingredients such as acid and fertiliser, used to boost the alcohol content to achieve a higher price.

The investigation found traces of fungicide in leading Champagne brands and discovered that experts struggled to distinguish between a £6.99 sparkling wine and a Champange three times the price.

Jancis Robinson, the wine writer, told the programme: "From my point of view perhaps about 30 per cent of all champagne is worth the money."

The British wine industry has fought to retain an exemption from food and drink labelling rules which means it does not have to list the additives.

John Corbet-Milward, spokesman for the Wine and Spirits Trade Association, said it is possible for drinkers to find out what is in their wine by talking to the maker or importer.

He said the use of different ingredients in varying quantities makes it difficult for producers to come up with an accurate label.

What if Beer Companies Told the Truth?

Would some of their labels say, “Brewed with pure Rocky Mountain spring water, GMO corn syrup, and fish bladder”?

If you like to kick back now and then with a cold one, you may not have given much thought to what’s in the bottle or can. Perhaps you were reassured by ads with wholesome images of sparkling mountain streams and barley rippling in the breeze, or by slogans [1] like “Budweiser: The Genuine Article.”

The reality is far less appetizing. The list of legal additives [2] to beer includes:

  • MSG
  • Propylene glycol (it helps stabilize a beer’s head of foam, though in high quantities it can cause health problems [3])
  • High-fructose corn syrup (HFCS)
  • Calcium disodium EDTA
  • Caramel coloring
  • FD&C blue 1, red 40, and yellow 5
  • Insect-based dyes
  • Glyceryl monostearate
  • Isinglass (see below)

You’re unlikely to see any of these industrial-sounding ingredients on a label, because listing ingredients in beer is voluntary. And when ingredients are listed, it may be a partial list—which is even more deceptive than having no list at all.

Several beers, for example, contain HFCS, most of which is genetically modified (GMO), and isinglass, a clarifying agent made from the swim bladder of fish [4]. But check most beer websites and they’ll tell you their “key ingredients” are “roasted, malted barley, hops, yeast, and water.” Perhaps the HFCS and isinglass were not “key” enough to merit inclusion on this list?

Some brands with less-than-wholesome ingredients:

  • Newcastle uses artificial caramel color to simulate the golden brown color that is supposed to come from toasted barley. “Caramel color” sounds innocuous, right? But it’s manufactured by heating ammonia and sulfites under high pressure, which may create carcinogenic compounds.
  • Miller Light, Coors, Corona, Fosters, Pabst, and Red Stripe use corn syrup, and Molson-Coors acknowledged that some of their corn is GMO.
  • Budweiser, Bud Light, Bush Light, and Michelob Ultra use dextrose (made from corn).
  • Anheuser-Bush uses corn.

The labeling regulations are confusing and capricious. Food is regulated by the FDA, and requires a Nutrition Facts panel, but alcohol is regulated by the US Treasury Department’s Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB). Unless it’s beer made with something other than malted barley, and then it’s regulated by the FDA and must carry a Nutrition Facts panel. States also have their own regulations, which can supersede those of TTB, but not of the FDA.

Marion Nestle, a nutrition professor at New York University, explained on her blog [5] why we still don’t know the ingredients in alcoholic beverages. In short, TTB has been procrastinating since 2007 on completing their rules for labeling of alcoholic beverages.

People with allergies to genetically modified corn are taking a chance when drinking beer, as there is no requirement that GMO ingredients be identified on the label. We told you early this year about the dangers of GMOs [6], and in 2011 about the dangers of sugar[7], especially fructose. So genetically modified fructose carries a one–two punch, and may be one of the more toxic foods that can be hiding in your food or drink—with nothing about it on the label.

Unfortunately for those with a sweet tooth, eschewing HFCS for plain old cane sugar may not be that much of an improvement. A recent study of mice fed a mixture of fructose and glucose showed that even moderate amounts of sugar shorten life span [8] (females fed sugar died twice as fast) and hamper reproduction (males were less likely to hold territory and sired fewer offspring).

While it certainly has its health benefits, and studies suggest that people who drink a little live a bit longer, alcohol—even without unsavory additives—has [9] more negatives than plusses. It introduces what is treated as a poison by your body and stresses the entire gastrointestinal system, from mouth to colon, making cancer possibly more likely, especially in the esophagus. It may increase the risk of heart disease, high blood pressure, and cirrhosis of the liver.

Not ready to give up the occasional brewski? According to the Food Babe [2], Sierra Nevada, Heineken, and Amstel Light are good choices, as they use only non-GMO grains and no artificial ingredients, stabilizers, or preservatives. German beers are subject to the “Reinheitsgebot” law mandating that beer be produced using only water, hops, yeast, malted barley, or wheat—you won’t have to guess what’s in them.

An obvious choice is certified organic beer, which cannot include GMOs and other harmful additives by law. And then there are the microbreweries. Many craft beer companies will give you a complete list of ingredients if you ask. Be warned, however: large beer companies are buying up microbreweries one by one, as Molson-Coors did with Blue Moon and Anheuser-Busch did with Goose Island Brewery.

The healthiest of all alcoholic beverages is not beer at all, but red wine. It naturally contains resveratrol [10], which appears to have anti-aging, cancer-preventing, cardio-protective, neuro-protective, and anti-diabetic effects. It’s also an anti-inflammatory and an antiviral to boot. As we noted in a recent article [11], red wine can also help clear bad bugs from your stomach. Cheers!

British backpacker dies after drinking methanol-spiked gin in Indonesia

A British backpacker died after drinking methanol-tainted gin in Indonesia, the latest death from poisoned alcohol in the archipelago.

Cheznye Emmons, 23, from Essex, started feeling sick a few hours after drinking from a bottle labeled “gin” that she and her boyfriend had purchased from a local store.

Within days she had lost her eyesight and was taken to a hospital in Medan, Sumatra, where she was put in an induced coma.

Her parents, who had traveled to Indonesia to be by her bedside, made the heartbreaking decision to turn off her life support machine on April 25.

"It just doesn't seem real – we're all just in shock,” Emmons’ older brother Michael was quoted by The Telegraph as saying.

"From what we understand, the shop would have poured the gin out of the original bottle and then replaced it with methanol.

"It was in the original bottle with the gin label on it.

"As far we're aware, the shop which sold the alcohol has been shut down and there's a police investigation.

"The British embassy is also looking into it."

Methanol is extremely poisonous and can cause blindness and death.

Media reports said high taxes had driven up the cost of wine and spirits in Indonesia, and unscrupulous shop owners try to “stretch the alcohol” by replacing it with a local spirit called arak, or adding methanol.

Emmons’ case is not unique.

The Courier Mail reported that an Australian man died in February after drinking a methanol-laced vodka mixer in Lombok. In December, an Australian schoolgirl was blinded after drinking a poisoned cocktail in Bali.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments